
The International Business Aviation Council (IBAC) is urging its affiliated national associations to lobby their governments to demand political pressure to block changes to the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU-ETS). The group, which represents business aviation at ICAO, has backed the EBAA’s opposition to proposals made by the European Commission’s Climate Action directorate-general on the grounds that changes would disproportionately affect the industry to the extent that some operators could find it impossible to comply with requirements.
Under proposals issued in July, the introduction of a new de minimis emissions threshold of 1,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide per company annually would bring many additional smaller operators under the EU-ETS mandate. According to IBAC, some members of the European Parliament want to further lower the de minimis threshold for EU-ETS compliance to just 250 tonnes. The group said this would bring around 1,000 more operators under the requirements of the legislation.
The EC also wants the scheme to apply to all flights from the European Economic Area to third-country destinations within a 5,000-kilometer (2,700-nm) radius of Frankfurt, Germany. IBAC says this will significantly increasing the number of flights from outside the European Union that would be subject to requirements.
As part of its rebuttal of the proposed changes, EBAA has also protested that they will subject business aviation to broader carbon-pricing obligations than airlines by being denied access to sustainable aviation fuel allowances and to the use of book-and-claim options. The group has also complained that the new structure would take no account of other passenger and carbon taxes levied by individual European Union member states, such as France, Portugal, Italy and the Netherlands.
IBAC director general Kurt Edwards has accused the EC of “sectoral bigotry” in consciously discriminating against business aircraft operators, which he said will be harmful to the viability of some companies. Edwards said excluding the industry from book-and-claim accounting for emissions is especially unreasonable since its companies commonly fly to airports where SAF is not available.
“In their supporting text, the European Commission said that business aircraft operators have the means and the resources to buy SAF without providing evidence of that,” he told AIN. “Why strip away the benefit of taking advantage of [SAF] technology?”
In what IBAC said would be a further divergence from the ICAO-backed CORSIA approach to achieving net-zero emissions for air transport by 2050, the EC intends to reduce the mtow threshold for EU-ETS from 5,700 kilograms (12,540 pounds) to 2,500 kilograms. Edwards said this will mean turboprop aircraft such as the Pilatus PC-12 and Daher TBM 980 would be covered by the scheme and its high cost of compliance and administration.
At the EBAA Week event in Brussels this week, IBAC representatives will introduce a new vehicle-tonne-kilometer metric that they are proposing for business aviation. According to Bruce Parry, senior advisor for industry affairs with Bombardier Aerospace, this would be a fairer way to calculate the sector’s emissions than the passenger-kilometer metric devised with airlines in mind.
Edwards said the EC’s allegedly discriminatory efforts to make EU-ETS compliance harder for business aviation companies are also unnecessary since the industry is strongly committed to decarbonization. “Part of the reasoning for excluding our operators from SAF allowances is that they believe we are more likely to electrify [aircraft] sooner, but this simply isn’t the incentive they think it is,” he concluded.
Ultimately, if the EC presses ahead with the proposed changes, IBAC has indicated that the industry may be forced to take legal action to challenge the new rules on grounds of discrimination. In June, lawyers acting for Dassault Aviation, with EBAA support, successfully challenged the process by which the European Commission had excluded business aviation from its “taxonomy” definition of environmentally sustainable activity. The European Union General Court in Luxembourg ruled that the industry had been excluded in an unfair and discriminatory way.